Questions? Toll-Free 877-347-6784

Birthday > Mystical / Myths / Fantasy Birthday Cards

Mystical Birthday Cards

Fairies, mermaids, and wizards galore! Our mystical birthday cards are perfect to send to the lover of the mystical in your life.

Card Categories
Loading...
Filter Results
Orientation
Portrait
Landscape
Custom Photos (Front)
None
1
2
3
4
5+
Custom Text (Front)
Yes
No
Shopper Testimonials
“I have been ordering your cards for years. I love the variety, ability to personalize and the reasonable cost. Family loves the personalization. Thank you for the great customer service.”
Shellie - Nov 9th, 2026
“I like that I can have a theme for Christmas this year snowmen (or snowpersons) last year it was trees. Can't remember the other years. Thank you for making it so easy to order.”
Phyllis - Nov 4th, 2026
Cards per Page:
Cards: 333 Pages: 12
Most Popular Newest Show adult cards
Grim reaper Selecting a New Blade for an Upcoming …
Birthday Heron and Bright Crescent Moon card
Fortune teller, Birthday for someone Very Special …
Birthday Card With Mermaid Tail May All Your Dream…
Kid Birthday With Cute Monster And Colorful Happy …
Fairy Birthday Greetings card
Birthday Fairy - Make a Wish card
Fairy Birthday card
Birthday Cyclops Getting Eye Exam at Optometrist c…
Birthday Fairy by Lake Magical Purple Garden Scene…
Happy Birthday - Green Fairy Card
Happy Birthday Foxglove Fairy White Flowers card
Happy Birthday Fairy card
General Birthday Fine Art Lake Fairy Watercolor Pa…
A little fairy card
Happy Birthday Fairy with Balloons card
Birthday Card With Rainbow Unicorn May Your Birthd…
Birthday for Girl or Woman Magical Birthday Toadst…
Magical Birthday Wishes Whimsical Unicorn Greeting…
Birthday, Someone special, Unicorn in Rainbow Colo…
Birthday Surreal Picture Bright Fantasy Birthday c…
Have a Magical Birthday Unicorn card
Happy Birthday Griffon card
Happy Birthday to a Sweet Girl with Unicorn on Cup…
Fantasy Birthday with Exquisite angel card
Birthday I Wish I Was A Sorcerer Cartoon Moonlight…
Magic Bird Happy Birthday card
Birthday Humor Born During the Chinese New Year of…
Custom Name Unicorn Pegasus Unicorn Mystical Magic…
Fairy Of The Earth Happy Birthday by Fairychamber …
Page: 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10
As Featured In