Questions? Toll-Free 877-347-6784

Birthday > Mystical / Myths / Fantasy Birthday Cards

Mystical Birthday Cards

Fairies, mermaids, and wizards galore! Our mystical birthday cards are perfect to send to the lover of the mystical in your life.

Card Categories
Loading...
Filter Results
Orientation
Portrait
Landscape
Custom Photos (Front)
None
1
2
3
4
5+
Custom Text (Front)
Yes
No
Shopper Testimonials
“I've been a customer for more years than I care to count! Always exceptional cards that my family looks forward to seeing (which I personalize for their birthdays, with them pictured of course).”
Laurie - Sep 21st, 2026
“Loved the option to edit the text. Best website for greeting cards.”
Linda - Sep 21st, 2026
more testimonials
Cards per Page:
Cards: 316 Pages: 11
Most Popular Newest Show adult cards
Birthday Beautiful Fairy with Dolphins and Full Mo…
Birthday Name Specific Illustrated Flower Fairy ca…
Birthday, Moonlight over the Ocean card
The Happy Birthday Troll on a Gothic Note card
Birthday Moon Goddess and Cat Crescent Moon Fantas…
Birthday Horse With Bright Wings Pegasus Birthday …
Birthday Tarot Another Trip Around the Sun with Da…
Mermaid Shakes Her Tail Fins on Her Birthday card
Gargoyle~belated birthday card
Birthday Mermaid Girl Discovering Her Present Unde…
Birthday Card - Unicorn Dreams card
Happy Birthday Roller Skating Dragon card
Happy Birthday Fantasy Crystal Ball card
Peace Fairy card
Chupacabra Happy Birthday card
Flower Fairy Butterfly Fantasy Illustration card
Sweet Lavender Fairy Birthday Wishes For You card
Space station birthday greeting card - out of this…
Mermaid Fairies Grant Sweet Birthday Wishes card
Rainbow Knight card
Mystical Magical Birthday with Wizard and Owl Cres…
Birthday with a Cute Purrmaid Happily Swimming in …
Happy Birthday - Witch Starry Night card
Birthday Furry Snow Animal Burrowing to Find It’s …
Sparkling Magical Happy Birthday Book of Life card
Happy Birthday Dragons card
Birthday Mystical Sphinx in Funny Hat card
Happy Birthday Dragon with Balloons card
As Day Breaks Triumphant White Unicorn Birthday ca…
Devil May Care Birthday card
Last
Next »
« Prev
First
Page: 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7
As Featured In