Questions? Toll-Free 877-347-6784

All Products

Can't find the perfect card?
Click here to request it
  • No additional cost
  • New designs within 24 hours
Filter Results

Category  reset

Custom Photos (Front)

Custom Text (Front)

Orientation

Adult Content

  • No  (555138)
  • Yes  (1586)

Artist

Shopper Testimonials
“My sister loved her card. It inspired her to ask for 'queen' status on her birthday!”
Evelyn - Oct 3rd, 2026
“It was very easy to find my not so in demand specialty card on this site. It is a lovely card with just the right wording. And I received it within a few days of ordering it!”
Kathryn - Oct 4th, 2026
more testimonials
Click to verify BBB accreditation and to see a BBB report.
Satisfaction Guarantee on Greeting Cards
  1. What is your delivery time?
  2. How much do cards cost?
  3. Do you offer bulk discounts?
  4. Is personalization free?
  5. Are these quality cards?
  6. How much does shipping cost?
  7. Who can I mail the cards to?
  8. How quickly are cards mailed?
  9. Do you ship outside of the US?
  10. Are envelopes included?
all products

> Congratulations > Lost a Tooth > 1st / First Tooth

1 - 16 of 16
Per page: 
Sort: 
View: 
Page  1  of 1
Congratulations, first tooth, star, happy teeth Congratulations, first tooth, star, happy teeth

Congratulations, first tooth, star, happy teeth

Product ID:1409178
Customize:Cover text, inside text
Artist:Gail Pepin
Inside Text:

Hip, hip, hooray! A new tooth is on its way! You can check for it every day. We are so proud of you and love you, too! Congratulations!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize Sell this card
You lost a tooth, cute cartoon tooth on hot pink sunburst background You lost a tooth, cute cartoon tooth on hot pink sunburst background

You lost a tooth, cute cartoon tooth on hot pink…

Product ID:1461220
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:MheaDesign
Inside Text:

Congratulations on losing your first tooth!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Congratulations on losing your first tooth, blue sunburst background Congratulations on losing your first tooth, blue sunburst background

Congratulations on losing your first tooth, blue…

Product ID:1461230
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:MheaDesign
Inside Text:

Congratulations on losing your first tooth!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Cartoon Talking Tooth Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Cartoon Talking Tooth

Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Cartoon…

Product ID:1594776
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Kate Taylor
Inside Text:

I hope the tooth fairy has been!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Tooth Fairy Congratulations Tooth Fairy Congratulations

Tooth Fairy Congratulations

Product ID:1598096
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Annie Lang
Inside Text:

I bet your smile is simply dazzling! Wishing you happy smiles as you celebrate this milestone event.

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Customizable Name Lost First Tooth Congratulations Stars Customizable Name Lost First Tooth Congratulations Stars

Customizable Name Lost First Tooth Congratulations…

Product ID:1600158
Customize:Cover text, inside text
Artist:Sandra Rose Designs
Inside Text:

What a special milestone to LOSE your FIRST TOOTH! It is the first of many more to come, as you watch your smile change and your adult teeth grow in!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize Sell this card
Lost First Tooth Congratulations Stars Lost First Tooth Congratulations Stars

Lost First Tooth Congratulations Stars

Product ID:1600160
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Sandra Rose Designs
Inside Text:

What a special milestone to LOSE your FIRST TOOTH! It is the first of many more to come, as you watch your smile change and your adult teeth grow in!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
You Got Your First Tooth Cute Congratulations You Got Your First Tooth Cute Congratulations

You Got Your First Tooth Cute Congratulations

Product ID:1617764
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:MheaDesign

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Congratulations on losing your first tooth cute tooth fairy Congratulations on losing your first tooth cute tooth fairy

Congratulations on losing your first tooth cute…

Product ID:1629886
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:MheaDesign
Inside Text:

Congratulations on losing your first tooth!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Tooth Fairy Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Tooth Fairy

Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Tooth…

Product ID:1670148
Customize:Cover text, inside text
Artist:Olivia A. Kneibler
Inside Text:

I'll be back again pretty soon. Many hugs and kisses, The Tooth Fairy XOXOXOXO

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize Sell this card
Congratulations on Losing First Tooth Girl in Green Dress Illustration Congratulations on Losing First Tooth Girl in Green Dress Illustration

Congratulations on Losing First Tooth Girl in…

Product ID:1699334
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Joyce Geleynse
Inside Text:

I heard your wiggly tooth has gone and left a great big space. I hope the fairy's given you some money in its place!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Super Tooth and Froggy Tooth Fairy Congratulations on First Lost Tooth Super Tooth and Froggy Tooth Fairy Congratulations on First Lost Tooth

Super Tooth and Froggy Tooth Fairy Congratulations…

Product ID:1060899
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Nicole Spencer
Inside Text:

Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth! Your Smile Looks Amazing!!!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Super Tooth Congratulations on First Lost Tooth Super Tooth Congratulations on First Lost Tooth

Super Tooth Congratulations on First Lost Tooth

Product ID:1060905
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Nicole Spencer
Inside Text:

I Heard you Lost your First Tooth! Your Smile Looks Amazing ... Congratulations!!!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Personalized Super Tooth Congratulations on First Lost Tooth Personalized Super Tooth Congratulations on First Lost Tooth

Personalized Super Tooth Congratulations on First…

Product ID:1060909
Customize:Cover text, inside text
Artist:Nicole Spencer
Inside Text:

I Heard you Lost your First Tooth! Your Smile Looks Amazing ... Congratulations!!!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize Sell this card
Congratulations on Losing First Tooth Blue Congratulations on Losing First Tooth Blue

Congratulations on Losing First Tooth Blue

Product ID:1294054
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Sandra Rose Designs
Inside Text:

That great smile will show your pride.

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card
Tooth Fairy Visit- Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth Tooth Fairy Visit- Congratulations on Losing Your First Tooth

Tooth Fairy Visit- Congratulations on Losing Your…

Product ID:1336800
Customize:Inside text only
Artist:Christie Black-Creations from the Heart
Inside Text:

Congratulations on losing your first tooth!

custom card enlarge add favorites personalize purchase Sell this card